Joel Moskowitz, president of Tools for Working Wood, submitted the following response to my "Letter from the Editor - Government is Failing Small Businesses (and Yet Expects So Much More from Us)." What are your thoughts on the subject?
Dear Rob,
For someone who publishes a magazine that I find so darn useful, I find it shocking that your editorial has such knee-jerk, inside-the-box thinking. Someone has to pay for health care. If it's private or public it doesn't matter; it's still an added cost. If it's the law and an added tax then it raises costs for everyone and there is no competitive downside.
For a magazine that has mentioned more than once that not paying the founders a salary and calling it sweat equity means you don't have a real business (or some such idea), not having an insured workforce also means you don't have a real business. It's a stupid way to save money because:
1) Top employees will demand health insurance in order to stay with you.
2) It's far, far easier to recruit top talent if you offer insurance.
3) It makes a lot more sense for employees to be able to go to a doctor when needed than to have sick people wandering around the workplace (and complaining).
If insurance were easily affordable, more and more people would take the plunge away from big companies to start-ups of all sorts. The only real issue is if insurance should flow through the employer and if there should be a public option. On the former case I don't think employers should be responsible for medical care, and the smart companies (Wal-Mart for instance, at least occasionally - I don't know their current opinion), have argued for an individual public option - but which such unimaginative thinking from the business community that isn't going to happen.
Since private insurance has shown no great efficiency over various public plans I can understand why the insurance industry has fought a public option tooth and nail, but certainly competition is competition. I pay taxes for protection against fire, crime, invasion and stability, and for an organized business environment, so I see no reason why adding another form of protection, such as medical care should not be included.
Personally as a president of a small company I would like to get out of the insurance business and concentrate on making money.
Sincerely,
Joel Moskowitz